When comparing ID Guard Offline vs GateKeeper Enterprise, the Slant community recommends ID Guard Offline for most people. In the question“What are the best offline password managers?” ID Guard Offline is ranked 4th while GateKeeper Enterprise is ranked 27th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pro It does not have the Internet permission
Pro Innovatively use phone's Security Chip to encrypt data
Pro Back up and restore data in a completely offline way
The app also has detailed instructions on how to back up or restore data, which is very nice to new users.
Pro Add file attachments
Pro No ads
Pro Biometric or master password authentication
Pro Find Back Master Password
Pro Password generator
Pro It has payment card templates
Pro OTP Authenticator
Save OTP authentication codes in the app, it can autofill the codes.
Pro Scan and fill on desktop browser
It is an offline password manager, but it can fill password into your desktop browser by launching the mobile browser on your phone to send an encrypted password to the browser extension.
Pro Account templates are terrific
The account templates are so powerful that you can save all your account security information in one record. For your google account, besides the password, you can save OTP, recovery code and email addresses. For Facebook, you can save emergency contacts as well. For Apple ID, the security questions can also be saved.
Pro Turn on 2FA for Apple ID without security question answers
Pro Advanced Phishing Detection
Now, ID Guard Offline (Android) can,
- identify FAKE apps to prevent them from stealing your passwords.
- identify insecure websites served via HTTP connection and warn you against passwords leaking.
- display information requested by Autofill, such as username, password, etc. to prevent malicious websites or apps from stealing your passwords by hiding password boxes. (A malicious website or app might hide the password box to make you mistakenly think that you are not filling password, but actually you are.)
Pro Automatic lock
GateKeeper automatically locks the computer as soon as the user leaves the proximity.
Pro Continuous authentication
Rather than traditional 2FA that only authenticates at one point in time, GateKeeper continues to authenticate even after the user is logged in. This way, there is truly 100% security 24/7.
Pro No passwords to type
Typing passwords sucks and this device makes it so you don't have to remember any passwords.
Pro Faster EHR login!
No complicated 2fa or extra steps. I login to my workstation and the passwords all auto-fill on websites and available for on-premise EHR.
Pro Password manager for computers and applications
Not just for websites, but get into your computer and software applications too.
Pro Automatic authentication
Doesn't rely on the user typing a password or an OTP code - works with presence.
Pro RDP and Thin Clients
When you login to an RDP session, the Gatekeeper key pushes your passwords through so you can use them with thin clients.
Pro Best customer service!
There's always something that we need help with and gatekeeper is always there to save us. Best customer service, ever. They dont treat you different for being a smaller client.
Pro Audit reports
No more wondering which employee logged into which workstation when.
Pro Touch to login
Using a key to touch the computer to login is so much easier than memorizing different passwords.
Pro Switch workstations without typing passwords again
Really fast login, so if you have a annoying timeout policy, gatekeeper keeps you logged in as long as you're still there.
Con It can't import from other password managers
Con Lack of desktop clients
It might seems that whole world is "mobile" now. But that's not true. A lot of people use their notebooks or even desktop computers to work from. Lack of Linux and Windows clients holds this back.
Con Apart from automations, it's no better than Keepass
Put a key file to a small pendrive and you're set. At least with Keepass you can sync the database and key file to reduce the effect of human errors.