When comparing Samsung Gear S vs Samsung Galaxy Watch 5, the Slant community recommends Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 for most people. In the question“What are the best smartwatches?” Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 is ranked 7th while Samsung Gear S is ranked 15th. The most important reason people chose Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 is:
The automatic workout tracking on the Galaxy Watch 5 is super accurate, pausing and resuming within seconds of you starting/stopping.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Stand-alone Connectivity
With access to 3G and 2G networks, as well as Bluetooth and WiFi, the Gear S keeps you connected, with or without your smartphone.
Pro Android Wear
Pro Auto without tracking
The automatic workout tracking on the Galaxy Watch 5 is super accurate, pausing and resuming within seconds of you starting/stopping.
Pro Health tracking
The Galaxy Watch 5 comes with all the health tracking you could want - heart rate, ECG, as well as body composition and continuous stress measurement.
Cons
Con Expensive
Depending on the carrier or if it's bought directly from Samsung price varies, but it costs over $300 regardless of it's supplier.
Con Very large
Even the smaller size (40mm) ends up looking pretty big, especially on smaller wrists.