When comparing Magic: The Gathering Online vs Pokémon Trading Card Game Online, the Slant community recommends Pokémon Trading Card Game Online for most people. In the question“What are the best digital Collectible Card Games on PC?” Pokémon Trading Card Game Online is ranked 15th while Magic: The Gathering Online is ranked 29th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro 1:1 to real world game
All card packs cost money, and just as much as they would at a store. With this you get a digital replacement for the real world game in that it behaves in the exact same manner of those that spend the time collecting can build up an arsenal of decks to compete with.
Pro Play Pokemon on your phone
Pro You get in-game cards by buying real-world cards
Cards can be won and bought with won in-game currency but you don't buy currency with real-world money like other games. Instead when you buy cards in the real-world you get a code for the equivalent amount of cards in-game, theme decks give you the exact same cards, and promo boxes gets you those promo cards.
Cons
Con Dated UI
MTGO is not newbie friendly in that the UI looks very dated and it can be difficult to navigate. This makes for a learning curve many are not willing to put up with.
Con Expensive
The digital version costs the same as the physical game, which doesn't seem completely fair.
Con Cannot play with friends
Unless you do it like the stream snipers.
Con Tablets are better for iOS and Android versions
Tablets used to be required, but can be played on any size screen now - you might not want to though.