When comparing Pumpkin Path - Logic Puzzle Game vs Monument Valley, the Slant community recommends Monument Valley for most people. In the question“What are the best offline Android games?” Monument Valley is ranked 1st while Pumpkin Path - Logic Puzzle Game is ranked 38th. The most important reason people chose Monument Valley is:
The gameplay for Monument Valley revolves around manipulating the environment in order to let your character proceed to the next level. It's similar to Fez in that it's obviously inspired by Escher paintings, requiring you to manipulate "impossible" architecture.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Ability to be played anywhere
You can play offline or online, online is needed for the FB leaderboard.
Pro Free with no in app purchases
Pro Lengthy gameplay
60 levels with increasing difficulty and 15hrs of game play
Pro New approach to playing logic puzzle games
Pumpkin Path is a 3D maze game, where the levels dynamically change as you move around, based on your moves made. This increases the difficulty for the opponent. If you cheat using power ups then the Ai may decide to also cheat when it gets stuck. The game uses true 3D environment, the user can zoom in or out in 3D.
Pro The scenery is beautiful and incorporates clever Escher inspired gameplay mechanics
The gameplay for Monument Valley revolves around manipulating the environment in order to let your character proceed to the next level. It's similar to Fez in that it's obviously inspired by Escher paintings, requiring you to manipulate "impossible" architecture.
Pro No need for internet connection with offline gameplay
Monument Valley allows for offline gameplay, meaning that the user does not need an internet connection to play once the game has been downloaded onto his/her device.
Pro Perfect balance of difficulty in puzzles
No puzzle is too difficult or too easy. Never frustrating.
Pro Illustrative soundtrack
The soundtrack really helps illustrate the beautiful surrounding world in which the game is set.
Cons
Con The game is too short
The base game only has ten levels that can be completed within 20 minutes.