When comparing Alice: Madness Returns vs Resident Evil HD Remaster, the Slant community recommends Resident Evil HD Remaster for most people. In the question“What are the best games on Steam with a female protagonist?” Resident Evil HD Remaster is ranked 22nd while Alice: Madness Returns is ranked 35th. The most important reason people chose Resident Evil HD Remaster is:
The developers have done a great job of balancing difficulty of the puzzles. You'll still have to look for clues, reading through documents and examining objects, but it won't ever feel daunting. It won't feel too easy either, giving you a sense of accomplishment when you open that secret passage or locked door.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Good story
The story is about the psychological problems of Alice in relation to her past. Throughout the game you collect the pieces of the puzzle that is Alice's story and eventually you uncover the truth.
Pro Smart coincidences
There are several times a person or a statement in Wonderland perfectly represents a real situation and it's effects. This is a sign of
an intelligent and hard work for this game.
The Dollmaker is a perfect example for this. The word Doll-maker is associated with the evil man and truth behind him and what he really does.
Pro Trippy art style
The art style of Alice: Madness Returns is a very psychadelic kind of fantasy art style that revolves around the theme of Alice in Wonderland, albeit with a darker approach.
Pro The puzzles feel just right
The developers have done a great job of balancing difficulty of the puzzles. You'll still have to look for clues, reading through documents and examining objects, but it won't ever feel daunting. It won't feel too easy either, giving you a sense of accomplishment when you open that secret passage or locked door.
Pro Immersive exploration
The entire game is set in a massive mansion and its surrounding area. It's very quiet, spacious, and has many locked doors that will pique your interest. You'll gradually unlock more of the mansion, slowly uncovering its mysteries. This includes hidden passages, secret laboratories, and rotting cellars, hiding many dark secrets. You're never quite sure what to expect next, but that's what it keeps it fresh and exciting throughout the entire game.
Pro Fixed camera angles create a cinematic experience
Resident Evil HD skillfuly balances visibility and tension with fixed camera angles. It can be the view from behind a fence as your character passes it by, giving you a sense of looming danger. It can be an upwards angle on a giant statue, making it seem more imposing. Or it can be the zoomed out view of a great hall to make the scale all the more impressive. Many details like this make Resident Evil HD more visually pleasing and atmospheric than most modern games.
Cons
Con Repetitive
The gameplay tends to get repetitive after a while. The campaign is around 15 hours long on average, although it's always about puzzles and pretty generic combat that's essentially just knife combat and a peppermill that functions as a sort of gatling gun.
Con Combat feels awkward at times
In various areas you won't be able to see the enemies on-screen because of the fixed camera angles. This might make combat somewhat unpleasant since you won't be sure if you're hitting the enemy or how far they are. The auto-aim function helps with that by pointing your character towards them, but you won't stay locked on, so you'll have to constantly readjust your aim.