When comparing Postico vs Navicat for PostgreSQL, the Slant community recommends Navicat for PostgreSQL for most people. In the question“What are the best GUI tools for PostgreSQL on Windows?” Navicat for PostgreSQL is ranked 3rd while Postico is ranked 10th. The most important reason people chose Navicat for PostgreSQL is:
The Navicat UI is extremely quick to respond to requests.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Native experience and clean user interface
Postico is a native OS X app which is available through Mac App Store. The UI is fast, responsive and integrates seamlessly with the OS.
Pro Created by an experienced developer in the field
Postico is the successor of PG Commander, an older Mac Posgres GUI tool which is also widely used. They are both maintained by the same person.
Pro Fast UI
The Navicat UI is extremely quick to respond to requests.
Pro Good autocomplete
Navicat offers a strong code completion feature.
Pro Saves queries by name
Pro Very stable
Cons
Con No multiple query tabs in the free trial version
To be fair, multiple windows / tabs IS a feature. It's just part of the paid version.
Con Commercial
Postico is a commercial app, with a one-time fee of $35. There is a free trial available.
Con Expensive
Navicat is quite expensive at $149 for the standard edition, and $199 for enterprise.