When comparing Universal Principles of Design, by William Lidwell vs Don't Make Me Think, the Slant community recommends Don't Make Me Think for most people. In the question“What are the best books on web design?” Don't Make Me Think is ranked 1st while Universal Principles of Design, by William Lidwell is ranked 5th. The most important reason people chose Don't Make Me Think is:
The book understands it's goals and has a clear purpose. How to get people to understand, and accomplish their goals on the site. As suggested by the name, the book is to the point and doesn't waste time.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Backs up well known theories
Many of the theories presented in the book will already be familiar to designers. However this book backs up the theories with data, additional research and examples that encourage the designer to consider the theories in different ways.
Pro Variety of theories
There are 125 different theories introduced in the book that cover a very wide range of relevant disciplines (such as psychology and biology).
Pro Short and focused
The book understands it's goals and has a clear purpose. How to get people to understand, and accomplish their goals on the site. As suggested by the name, the book is to the point and doesn't waste time.
Pro Clear examples
Many visuals and real world examples of good design are provided, making it an easy to understand and read book.
Cons
Con Theories are not described in depth
Each theory has two pages; one page with visual examples, and another page with a written description. These act more as an introduction to the various theories as they don't go into much depth.
Con Poor binding quality
There have been complaints with the quality of binding with the 2nd edition book.
