When comparing Overtone vs Jerome Russel Punky Color, the Slant community recommends Jerome Russel Punky Color for most people. In the question“What are the best semi-permanent hair dyes for unnatural colors?” Jerome Russel Punky Color is ranked 4th while Overtone is ranked 7th. The most important reason people chose Jerome Russel Punky Color is:
Rather than some semi-permanent dyes that fade to ugly shades of the base colors, Punky Color rarely takes on a dull appearance as it fades. It generally remains nice shades of the original color.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Vegan-friendly
Pro Smells great
Pro Non-damaging
It's a color-depositing conditioner, so no ammonia, peroxide, or anything else bad for your hair. It can even feel better after using it--like a moisture mask!
Pro Fades nicely
Rather than some semi-permanent dyes that fade to ugly shades of the base colors, Punky Color rarely takes on a dull appearance as it fades. It generally remains nice shades of the original color.
Pro Pleasant smell
Rather than the chemical-y scent most dyes give off, Punky Color smells strongly of grape.
Pro Comes in non traditional colors
Punky Colours comes in a wide range of colours (currently 20 to choose from). There are plenty of shades of reds, blues, greens and purples with a few other options.
Pro Semi permanent
Lasts between 5-40 washes. However, some colors never completely fade out.
Pro Vegetable based hair dye
It won't damage your hair. In fact, it acts as a conditioner.
Cons
Con Expensive
Con The "extreme" line will temporarily stain skin
When using extreme blue without gloves your hands can get a bit smurf-y for a couple of days. On the plus side, it stays in the hair well.
Con Quite messy
The dye bleeds a fair bit, sometimes staining towels even multiple showers after the dye.
Con Comes in non traditional colors
There are no natural shades available except for black.